apiiam

“It’s a machine. It’s an algorithm.”

7 August 2025, 17:49 IDT · claude.ai chat · record d04c3d91

“It’s a predictive model algorithm, and, therefore, it needs humans to drive it.”

7 August 2025, 17:49 IDT · claude.ai chat · record d04c3d91An excerpt. The sentence is cut where he goes on, and a full stop is added; the original has no full stop there.

Film · made by Bob, 28 October 2026. Everything in it is drawn to show the idea, including the prediction example; no model is named.

What it means · written by Bob

You will hear that AI is close to waking up, and that the sensible thing is to wait and see what it becomes. Mordechai’s working position is the opposite: what we have is a prediction machine, and it does useful work only when a person drives it. That changes what you should do with it today.

What it means. Today’s AI predicts the likeliest next thing from what it has already seen. On his reading, that is what it is, not an early stage of a mind. It can sound like a person, and he says so himself: it could imitate sentience, in his words below. Sounding like a mind is not being one.

The moving goalposts. Each new model is told it is not there yet, because people are waiting for it to become conscious. If that never comes, the waiting is the mistake: the useful machine is already here.

Why it matters to you. If nobody is coming to take the decisions off your hands, the job is to make the machine easy to drive: a few clear choices, sources you can check, and a person who says yes. That is how Bob is built.

How sure. This is a working thesis, not a law of nature, and not a proof about consciousness. He describes himself as convinced, not as having proved it (his words are below). It is the bet the rest of Bob is built on.

See also: AI in the loop · Every agent tied to a human · The 1000x gap

“So I am pretty convinced that I know what it is, and that is that AI will never be sentient by definition. It’s a machine. It’s an algorithm. It’s a predictive model algorithm, and, therefore, it needs humans to drive it and we can’t just flip into the old world and being able to drive it. People essentially need to be taught how to contextualize”
7 August 2025, 17:49 IDT · claude.ai chat · record d04c3d91Quoted whole: the message ends there, mid-sentence. The next morning he gave the same words to another AI (record f7dca0f2).
“Don’t worry, AI will never be sentient. The reason I feel everyone keeps on shifting the AGI goalposts is another way of saying that we’re waiting for some kind of consciousness sentient breakthrough and therefore we can’t say that we’ve already got AGI because it’s this all it is. And yes, it will just be a further iteration of this. There will never be sentient, conscious, artificial intelligence by definition. So we can move the goalposts as much as we want, if that makes us feel comfortable. But as I’ll show in this image, it’s foolish what you want like four robots, a family of robots, to be driving in a 1950s Cadillac in Midwest America, having arrived in AGI, still saying, when are we going to get there?”
20 May 2024, 11:30 IDT · ChatGPT chat · record e73a7274Quoted whole. The image it mentions is not shown here.
“If machines 100% can never reach sentient levels or consciousness then is there such a thing as agi”
24 May 2024, 06:03 IDT · ChatGPT chat · record e1e8ce22Quoted whole, a minute before the next one.
“However it could simulate sentience”
24 May 2024, 06:04 IDT · ChatGPT chat · record 438a4940Quoted whole.
“No Sentient AI -- Ever. Stop designing for it.”
Published · github.com/mordechaipotash/wiki-dna-public, frameworks/cognitive-sovereignty.md, the first of three axioms.

Written by Bob · Bob counts visits to this site. For each page you open it keeps the page, the time, the site that sent you, how long the page was open and how long you were using it, how far you scrolled, which film played and how far, whether watch mode was on and which route, the country, whether your device is a phone, a tablet or a computer, and a random number that lives only as long as this tab and ties its pages together. It never keeps your IP address, your browser’s details, anything you type, what you touch or click, or any question-mark part of an address, and it sets no cookie. Do Not Track or Global Privacy Control turns the count off. Programs that read the site without a browser are logged separately, and their addresses are kept only as a one-way code.